Article
Malcolm Hawker's The Data Hero Playbook (2025) argues that Chief Data Officers underperform not because of missing tools or frameworks, but because of mindset. Drawing on his years as a Gartner analyst and over sixty interviews from his CDO Matters podcast, Hawker adapts Carol Dweck's (2006) growth versus fixed mindset framework into a “positive” versus “limiting” spectrum, then builds an operational playbook around customer centricity, formal product management, value engineering, and an agile “Data Strategy MVP.” This review finds the book genuinely useful, though not every claim persuasive. Naming his own former employer as part of the problem took real nerve. But the book leans heavily on individual agency, and its evidence is entirely qualitative and self-selected, which understates how much of what it diagnoses, short tenures, resourcing gaps, the incentives running through the analyst-consultant-vendor world, sits beyond any one leader's mindset to fix.
Scroll to read the preview. Download for the complete document.
References
Dweck, C. S. (2006). Mindset: The new psychology of success. Random House.
Goudhaman, S., & Kaur, J. (2026, July 28). The Coming Wave: Technology, Power and the Twenty-first Century’s Greatest Dilemma [Book review]. European International University Publishing. https://publishing.eiu.ac/research-article/the-coming-wave-technology-power-and-the-twenty-first-centurys-greatest-dilemma/
Goudhaman, S., & Taluja, K. (2026, July 28). Co-Intelligence: Living and Working with AI [Book review]. European International University Publishing. https://publishing.eiu.ac/research-article/co-intelligence-living-and-working-with-ai/
Hawker, M. (2025). The Data Hero Playbook: Developing your data leadership superpowers. Wiley.
Kaur, J., Taluja, K., & Goudhaman, S. (2026, August 17). Book Review: Educating Decision Makers [Book review]. European International University Publishing. https://publishing.eiu.ac/research-article/book-review-educating-decision-makers/
Kotter, J. P., & Heskett, J. L. (1992). Corporate culture and performance. Free Press.
Laney, D. B. (2018). Infonomics: How to monetize, manage, and measure information as an asset for competitive advantage. Routledge.
Nadella, S. (2017). Hit refresh: The quest to rediscover Microsoft's soul and imagine a better future for everyone. HarperCollins.
Metrics are updated in real time as the article is accessed and downloaded.
Comments
2A very insightful and well-balanced review. I particularly appreciated how the review goes beyond summarizing The Data Hero Playbook and critically examines the role of mindset alongside organizational factors. The discussion on resource constraints, leadership tenure, and the limitations of self-selected qualitative evidence adds valuable depth. Overall, the review provides a thoughtful perspective on the challenges CDOs face in translating data strategy into measurable organizational value.
Leave a Comment
This is such a thoughtful and well-balanced review. I really liked how you engaged with Hawker’s central argument rather than simply summarizing the book. The discussion around mindset, leadership, and organizational change is particularly interesting, especially because the challenges faced by CDOs often seem to exist at both an individual and structural level. Your point about the book placing a lot of emphasis on individual agency really stood out to me. While mindset and leadership clearly matter, factors like organizational incentives, resource constraints, short leadership tenures, and the wider analyst-consultant-vendor ecosystem can significantly influence what a leader is actually able to change.
I also appreciated the criticism of the book’s evidence base. The qualitative interviews provide valuable insights and real-world perspectives, but questioning whether a self-selected sample can fully support such broad conclusions is important. At the same time, Hawker’s willingness to critique his former employer adds an interesting dimension to the book and, as you pointed out, takes a certain amount of courage. Overall, I really liked that your review recognizes the practical value of the playbook while still questioning some of its assumptions and limitations. It makes the review feel genuinely analytical rather than simply positive or negative.